|
|
How
to find journal articles on CMT
Linda here - If you are looking for medical journal articles relevant
to your specific type of CMT or CMT symptoms we thought we'd ask Ian
Gordon, Coordinator Brock Business Information Service (BBIS)Head, Reference
Information Services Sciences Librarian at Brock University, the person
who has been doing our searches for many years, how you can go about finding
your own data on CMT. If you are on the Internet though, CMTNEWS.com will
be bringing you updated lists of journal articles if possible with their
abstracts only. There are copyrights to consider. An abstract is the paragraph
under the title that puts the entire paper in a nutshell for you. If you
want the entire journal article, this will tell you how to get it. Now,
to Ian.
Linda - Ian, thanks for all your work on our behalf through the
years and thanks for this interview. Tell me, please, how can people who
are on the WWW find research journal articles on CMT besides CMTNEWS.com?
What medical journal web sites offer them?
Ian G. - CMT-related research is published exclusively in peer-reviewed
medical journals and tends not to surface on the Internet, in the news,
other media or in magazines. CMT articles are published in any number
of journals, but I have noted that most articles are published in a small
number of titles such as Neurology, Muscle & Nerve, Motor Control,
Neuromuscular Disorders, etc. Rather than browsing through publishers'
web sites on a regular basis it is recommended that searchers link to
resources similar to CMTNEWS.com or MEDLINEplus Health Information for
current research and general information. It is a common mistake to think
that CMT-related research is indexed in Internet journal aggregators and
databases such as ingenta HighWire Press, Free Medical Journals, PubList,
or PubMed Central.
These resources do not usually capture enough CMT research. However,
most (if not all) CMT-related research is eventually indexed in the EMBASE
or MEDLINE (PubMed) databases. I would recommend concentrating your efforts
on effectively using the U.S. National Library of Medicine's (NLM) PubMed
database to save valuable time and energy.
Linda - If a person is not on the Internet, what avenues can they
take to search out articles?
Ian G. - A good question. In the rush to re-invent access to the
medical research literature, paper resources have all but disappeared.
A significant majority of medical sciences journals will only be available
in electronic format within the next five years. Contacting a local Health
Sciences Librarian through a college, university, clinic, foundation,
public or hospital library would be an excellent first step in having
someone help you identify your information needs, resources at your disposal,
and how to repeat your search request on a regular basis. A personal e-mail
address and access to the Internet are becoming increasingly important
if not crucial in your quest for information. Be persistent and don't
be afraid to ask for assistance.
Linda - What strategies do I use to maximize the relevancy of
my search results?
Ian G. - Most researchers exclusively use the US National Library
of Medicine's PubMed (MEDLINE) database. Searching is free, the content
is up to date and the search engine is very flexible. It is important
to remember that any PubMed search results are only as good as the questions
you ask the database. A good search utilizes a series of natural language
keywords ie. hereditary and neuropathy and motor and/or the appropriate
NLM's MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) ie. Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease.
Continue to test the database using a series of repeating strategies,
don't forget to write them down, and then search the database on a regular
database adjusting when appropriate. Check out the PubMed tutorial linked
to the database home page. Once again, find a health sciences professional
that has mastered PubMed, take them out to lunch, and have them show you
how to exploit the database.
Linda - How can I obtain articles once I have identified what
I want?
Ian G. - Hospital and academic libraries pay big bucks for subscriptions
to journals for the exclusive use of their research and teaching communities.
Nothing of value is free and this is certainly the case for peer-reviewed
journals and their articles. Searching the Internet for library catalogues
may not help you identify locations for print or online copies of articles.
Increasingly libraries are linking with consortiums, document retrieval
services and health sciences' libraries to connect with online journal
article providers and publishers such as Canada's CISTI and the NLM's
Loansome DOC. However, too many individuals are on the outside looking
in when wanting to order individual articles. Once again, contact your
local library and ask for assistance in identifying local, regional, academic,
commercial and international document service providers.
Linda - How flexible and expensive are these document retrieval
services?
Ian G. - Most requested articles can be delivered within 48 hours
by mail or fax. Copyright restrictions limit the distribution of articles
in electronic format. Charges start at $10 US and can climb to $50 per
article. Flexibility comes at a price. The more eclectic and rush the
request ... the greater the charge. Although some scholastic journals
are beginning to supply articles directly from their web page using a
credit card, this service is the exception rather than the rule. I would
recommend working with individual health professionals working at facilities
that already provide document delivery and have agreements with established
document retrieval services. This would increase the number of options
and usually lowers the average price of articles ordered on a regular
basis.
Linda - What research areas am I missing when using traditional
databases and Internet resources?
Ian G. - Professional online searchers know when to test and try
alternate medical databases, resources, and contacts. However, CMT-related
research tends not
to fall within these non-traditional media sources. Chasing down that
elusive or grey-literature article is very time consuming. It is my observation
that CMT-related research lends itself to serious researchers who exchange
information using traditional and scholarly means of communication. A
good resource to begin this type of search is the New York Academy of
Medicine's Grey Literature Page. There are many good applied health sciences
meta-web pages and discussion lists that will give you a head-start on
finding and retrieving information. McMaster University Tom Flemming's
Health Care Information Resources web page is an excellent resource. These
contacts and others in your area are great people to know and utilize
in your search for current research.
Linda - Thanks very much, Ian. We know that doctors cannot be
up on all the research all the time. Many of us like to know what is happening
so we can better inform our doctors should a new finding be made concerning
our particular type of CMT or a specific symptom. Your information will
help us all keep up to date on current research.
MEDLINE plus Health Information
http//www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/charcotmarietoothdisease.html
ingenta
http//www.ingenta.com/
HighWire Press
http//highwire.stanford.edu/
Free Medical Journals
http//www.lib.uiowa.edu/hardin/md/ej.html
PubList
http://www.publist.com/
PubMed Central
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/index.html
PubMed (MEDLINE)
http//www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi
CISTI
http://www.nrc.ca/cisti/docdel/docdel_e.shtml
NLM's Loansome DOC
http//www.nlm.nih.gov/pubs/factsheets/loansome_doc.html
New York Academy of Medicine's Grey Literature Page
http://www.nyam.org/library/greylit/
MEDLIB-L
http://www.mlanet.org/discussion/medlibl.html
Health Care Information Resources (Tom Flemming)
McMaster University Health Sciences Library
http://wwwhsl.mcmaster.ca/tomflem/top.html
Ian Gordon, Coordinator Brock Business Information Service (BBIS)Head,
Reference Information Services Sciences Librarian
http://www.brocku.ca/library/research/chem/igbio.htm
http://www.brocku.ca/library/services/BBIS.html
|